I've heard that both Redline and Amsoil work well. Personally, I'm a Royal Purple Max Gear man, but for no real reason, other than that I used it in the past and my transmission didn't explode or anything. Mobil 1 also makes a 75W90 gear oil, and their motor oils are top notch.
I would say that it doesn't matter, but when I was going to change mine (still haven't gotten around to it on the Eclipse) I found
this thread that has a bunch of dudes bickering over GL-3 vs. GL-5 oil.
So I'd be wary of generic/store brand GL-5 lube, as it
may be bad for our synchros. It's probably fine, but as with insurance, tires, and condoms, I think it's better to spend a little more for peace of mind.
Both the
Redline and the
RP specifically state that they will NOT harm any soft metal components, unlike some GL-5 oils. The Amsoil and Mobil 1
don't make such a claim.
So when I do change mine, I'm gonna go with Redline or Royal Purple.